Faculty of Education - Theses
Permanent URI for this collection
Search Results
1 - 10 of 20
-
ItemThe value of library advisory committees( 1996)The study reported in this thesis investigated the value of Victorian university library advisory committees to committee members, with particular reference to their liaison function. A review of the literature gave some indication of their value. It also indicated that their liaison function was wide ranging and successful to varying degrees. However, the literature focused on these aspects from the point of view of librarians. There is a paucity of literature that articulated the views of non-librarian committee members, or investigated the value of library advisory committees from their perspective. It was the aim of the present study to redress this imbalance and investigate the value of library advisory committees, thus highlighting their benefits and disadvantages, for both librarians and non-librarians alike. The methodology used in the study was a survey using a self-administered questionnaire. The sample consisted of all members of all library advisory committees in four major Victorian universities. In addition to closed questions, the questionnaire used many open questions in order to draw out members' attitudes to and perceptions of their committee. The results of the survey indicated that on many aspects of committee operations and functions, committee members have parallel views regardless of whether they are librarians or non-librarians; consequently a profile of the typical committee member emerged. These results suggested that committees are functioning successfully and are valuable to their members, particularly as a means of liaison. However, it was notable that, in relation to policy issues, the views and priorities of librarians and non-librarians differed significantly. Unlike librarians, non-librarians were more likely to be of the opinion that their committee should offer more opportunity for policy input and involvement. The present study also revealed that more work needs to be done to determine the value of library advisory committee for students.
-
ItemAn evaluation of an orientation to higher education studies program( 1996)This study is an evaluation of the effectiveness of an Orientation to Higher Education Studies program presented at the Footscray campus of Victoria University of Technology (VUT) in February 1994, to new and continuing students who perceived themselves to be underprepared for university studies in general, and for meeting the standards required for written assignments in higher education in particular. The investigation was undertaken to gain insight into the strengths and weaknesses of the program's present curriculum, delivery techniques and organisational details, but, more importantly, it sought to better understand the potential short term and medium term effects for students of participation in the program. Deeper understandings of these issues will allow the presenters to make informed decisions regarding the development and delivery of future orientation programs for non-traditional students who enter higher education studies. It is also anticipated that this work will contribute to the current interest in the experiences of students in the first year of undergraduate degrees. A variety of methods was used to collect data for the study, including surveys, a questionnaire and interviews. The informants included the participants in the program, five case study students, lecturing staff and an independent assessor. Whilst data gathered through the questionnaire were useful in providing background information, it was investigation into the five case study students' experiences that gave deeper insight into the short and medium term effects on students' attitudes and actions with respect to the preparation of their first written assignment. The evaluation revealed that students from diverse non-traditional backgrounds can gain much from participating in such a program, particularly if it is complemented by the provision of on-going support . As well as identifying the benefits which occurred for the case study students, some limitations of the program were also revealed.
-
ItemProvision for students experiencing learning difficulties in independent, single campus, Protestant secondary girls' schools in Victoria( 1996)This study examines the support policies and provisions for students experiencing learning difficulties in five Protestant, independent, secondary girls' schools in Victoria. A multiple case study, utilising special teacher interviews and surveys of students' parents, was preferred. Supplementary information came from examination of school related documentation, school directories and selected interviews with students, parents and education professionals. Schools' reluctance to provide sensitive information impeded data collection in this study. Schools would not allow direct access to families and two even refused to forward a survey to students' parents. During interviews teachers showed considerable reluctance to share information concerning numbers of students experiencing learning difficulties, selection procedures and programs. Four major influences were revealed in the study: religion, government policies, funding and market forces. Other significant issues emerging included teachers' expressed need for on-going teacher training, and concern about the Disability Discrimination Act (1992). Parents highlighted the need to preserve student confidentiality. Both teachers and parents expressed positive views of the wide range of support services available in their schools, particularly increased parent involvement, inclusive/integrated education and the need for increased funds. Christian ethics rather than Protestantism influenced school provisions and hidden agendas revealed were selective enrolment practices and competition among the schools. Five recommendations were formulated: the need to clarify the implications of the 1992 Disability Discrimination Act for independent schools, further inter-school cooperation, employment of special education staff in all independent schools, formation of a parent lobby and further theological research into the religious and social responsibilities of church founded schools.
-
ItemIntroducing a gifted program in a rural secondary school( 1996)The study reported here outlines the steps taken to address a problem in the field of Education in a rural, secondary school. The problem, "What can be done to cater for the needs of gifted students in Years 7 and 8?" was posed by a member of staff of this school. He recognised that there was a need for an interventionist, in this case an external consultant, to undertake research on the existing educational setting, with members of the school community. The external consultant had expertise in the area of gifted programming, and also the necessary time to devote to lead the research which needed to be carried out. Action Research was chosen as a methodology which would be appropriate in this real-life situation. It involved the process of problem-solving through cycles of planning, acting and reflecting. It was a means of identifying and implementing a practical solution to a practical problem and, it was a method of carefully examining a practice and bringing about change in that practice. The process of change involved the participation of people who were part of the problem, viz. a number of administrators and teachers. These staff members were prepared to become part of a planning team instrumental in bringing about change in the learning environment of the school. The external consultant was also part of the planning team. The planning team gathered relevant data relating to current provisions for highly-able students, reflected on the data, planned appropriate action, acted and reflected on the action. This cyclical process utilised the reflection component to modify any procedural steps, thereby commencing the next cycle with substantive issues arising from the reflective practice. Through the 'Action Research process, significant attitudinal and structural changes occurred in the school setting involving administrators, teachers, students and parents. A definition of giftedness was accepted and a Talent Pool of highly able students was identified. In addition, community involvement was initiated, a resource pool of mentor volunteers was compiled and a Mentor program commenced. One of the outcomes of the process of change was the acceptance of future directions for the school in the area of gifted education. A number of proposals was accepted into the school structure for 1997, viz. the blocking of English periods in Years 7, 8 and 9 for subject acceleration, the continuation of the Mentor program and the deployment of interested staff in the gifted program. Action Research provided the means of improving a practice by the undertaking of new action in the form of a Mentor program for Year 7 students. This was a provision which was envisaged as being part of an extended gifted program in 1997. New direction for the following cycle of action focused on the problem, "What can be done to establish a comprehensive gifted program throughout the school?" The emphasis had shifted from the Year 7 level to a total-school approach, leading to a new perception of the problem and a new cycle of planning and action.
-
ItemVertical grouping of year 9 and 10 classes and the resultant classroom dynamics : a case study( 1996)The research questions on which this study are based are to do with issues about whether students at different ages can successfully study and learn together in the same class. The particular ages under examination in this study are those corresponding to Year 9 and 10 students. These students were studied to determine if they belonged to separate groups. The adolescent and social psychology literature explored suggested that the two year levels contained individuals of widely differing developmental levels and thus the research was designed to see how the vertical grouping (composite) of Year 9 and I0 classes effected the learning of the students. Via a Case Study design it was found that the internal interactions between individuals within single year level classes were different to those found in the composite class. (n the Year 9 class studied the students tended to only work with a select group of their friends whereas in the Year 10 class the students seemed to form an united and congenial group. The composite class was found to be composed of two distinct sub groups, a Year 9 group and a Year 10 group, each reflecting the characteristic interactions of their particular year level. Group work was used as a method of facilitating the communication between the two year levels in the composite class. This methodology did produce some positive results with increased communication between the two sub-groups at the completion of the research. During the research it was noted that group work has to be carefully structured and monitored if it is to have positive results. Webb (1982a) found that if students in groups ask questions and do not receive answers then this structure in fact can be detrimental, to their achievement. The effect of non-responsive communication within small group work could be further studied to ensure that this method of promoting cooperation in composite classes is effective.
-
ItemCurriculum coordination in practice( 1996)The implementation of whole-school curriculum change is a challenge faced by principals and senior staff with curriculum leadership responsibilities. Success depends on the cooperation and commitment of all teachers in a school, so that curriculum leaders require skills for manoeuvring groups of teachers towards a common goal. In Victorian government secondary schools the Curriculum Coordinator, an experienced teacher, is charged with overseeing curriculum change, and this customarily entails chairing a Curriculum Committee, the composition of which is invariably dominated by teachers. Schwab (1983) writes about the creation of a similar role in American schools, and proffers suggestions for the role and training of a curriculum coordinator and the composition of a curriculum committee, in order to encourage a refocussing on the liberal democratic traditions of education. This study uses Schwab's views as a reference point for examining the work of three experienced Curriculum Coordinators in Victorian government schools, who shared their stories with the author, himself a practising Curriculum Coordinator. Each participant in the study was asked to reflect on a Critical Incident of whole-school curriculum change, for which they had responsibility, and which influenced the ways in which they carried out the role of Curriculum Coordinator. The sharing of these reflections benefits both researcher and participant alike (Tripp, (1994)) and can offer insights into the skills and knowledge employed by effective curriculum leaders. Interpretation of the Critical Incidents provided a framework by which curriculum change can be analysed. The effect of the educational culture of a school, the status of the Curriculum Coordinator in the school and the extent to which the proposed curriculum change affects existing participant areas cumulatively influence the successful implementation. A number of writers identify teachers as inhibitors of change (eg: Cowie (1995), Weiss (1995) and Little (1990)), and the management and communication skills of effective Curriculum Coordinators are tested by this resistance. The stories presented confirm the notion of curriculum leadership as a practical, multi-faceted activity, and each participant has developed professionally through the practical execution of their roles. While each story is unique, the participants shared a common view of whole-school curriculum leadership as a collaborative exercise, focussed on improving educational outcomes for their students.
-
ItemFundraising in seven independent schools in Victoria : a pilot study( 1996)Structured fundraising is being formalised in independent schools through the establishment of development offices. Money raised through development aims to fill the gap between incoming money from fees and government grants and programs and resources considered necessary to provide exemplary education. However, development in schools is not only concerned with monetary gain. To achieve financial success, development officers must identify their supporters. To this end, friend raising is assuming greater importance in schools. Alumni and parents are nurtured to form a solid donor base within the school community. This study was designed to look at the development work being undertaken in seven independent schools in Victoria. The various fundraising strategies of these schools are described in the contexts of each of the selected schools' histories. Much of the development work being undertaken is influenced by the American experience. Australian independent schools can learn from the American experience. A model of the events and stages that appear from this pilot study is proposed as a contribution to ideas and concepts to offer interesting points for further study. The question of who constitutes the donor base and how development officers can identify this group is investigated. The types of programs to which donors give are also explored. Libraries are one area of schools which are likely to require substantial injection of funds, particularly as the use of new information technology is adopted in schools. Librarians need to be aware of the fundraising process within their school and any likely budgetary implications for their department. They can advise on aspects of fundraising where they have special expertise. The logistics of fundraising in schools frequently involves the use of volunteers. The study investigates the attitudes of development officers to this unpaid workforce, and if and how it can be used most effectively to assist development in schools. Librarians can be useful in this aspect because they have a long history of effective volunteer use in library programs. This is a descriptive study of development and fundraising practices in seven independent schools in Victoria. The study examined how fundraising is conducted by means of structured interviews with development officers responsible for implementation of development tasks and questionnaires to librarians in the same schools to expose specific aspects of the fundraising process in a school situation. Findings from this purposive sample of the population are not representative of all independent schools and refer only to the schools concerned. The data sheds light on aspects of fundraising and development practices and may be useful as reference for other independent schools. The study contributes to a better understanding of some of the factors that would be useful to explore further in a larger study of development and fundraising in schools. The issue of philanthropy in Australian schools is one which is currently of great importance given that an increasing number of independent schools are considering getting involved in development offices and fundraising activities.
-
Item'With a smile in her voice' : a life of Jean Lawson 1908-1986( 1996)Jean Lawson was born in England in 1908 and migrated to Australia with her parents in 1914. Educated in private schools and at the Universities of Sydney and Melbourne, she had an exceptionally varied career for a woman of her generation, becoming a teacher, acting headmistress and school counsellor, a radio and stage actress and radio broadcaster, a senior officer in the wartime Women's Auxiliary Australian Air Force (WAAAF) and a writer. She was also an active member of the Melbourne Lyceum Club and of the Christian Science Church and she participated in a range of voluntary community activities. With interests spanning the sciences and the humanities, she was a well known figure in Melbourne's educational and cultural circles. Her life offers insights into several aspects of twentieth century education, particularly that of women - the role of small private schools in the education of middle class women in the first half of this century, the experience of female students in science faculties in the interwar years, the wartime training of WAAAF airwomen and officers, the impact of educative radio for children in the 1940s and 1950s and the nature of career counselling for girls in the fast changing world of the 1960s and 1970s. Thus rather than providing a traditional account which would spotlight Jean Lawson, throwing her life into a kind of isolation, while endeavouring not to diminish her own contribution in a variety of fields, her life has been used as a focus for exploring the wider experience of women involved in similar events and interests. Given her ability to alter direction and reinvent herself as circumstances changed, her life has also been considered in terms of the formation of female subjectivity and since much of her writing was autobiographical, theoretical issues concerning biography and autobiography have also been central.
-
ItemThe construction of art in the secondary classroom: an investigation of the theories of Pierre Bourdieu( 1996)This thesis examines aspects of the theories of Pierre Bourdieu as they apply to art education. The study investigates whether Bourdieu's theories are supported by the real life histories of teachers and students. The research utilises the life history approach to investigate three factors which Bourdieu argues are significant in determining a student's chances of success in art education. The three factors are the socio-economic background of the student, the way in which art education tends to construct correct ways of making art and viewing art, and the values of art and schooling as reproduced through the family. This thesis shows how complex the structures are which construct what is taught in schools, and argues that altering the way teachers teach art does not necessarily alter what is valued by the teacher within the art classroom. The thesis discusses the way boundaries are constructed for students and that these boundaries influence the way students make and talk about art. This thesis argues, therefore, that for students to be successful within art education they must adhere to the parameters set by the teachers and the school.
-
ItemCan the incorporation of a structured pre-primary curriculum improve primary scholastic performance?( 1996)Primary and secondary educational reforms seeking quality and accountability are placing top-down pressure on early childhood education to become more defined and assessable in preparation for future learning. State and Federal government policies advocate set curriculum with definable results. Such trends are also observed overseas. The aim is for early childhood education to be more relevant to the rest of the child's learning and to the demands of the time. A large body of professionals within early childhood education view this as an intrusive, restrictive and regressive approach which is inconsistent with what years of research have taught us about early childhood education. They maintain that early childhood education is a stage in its own right and does not need to be altered to match another. Their main view is that each child learns individually to full potential via firsthand experiences through play under the guidance of a qualified educarer. Frameworks, and curricular continuity are seen as restrictions of such freedom. Generally accepting this premise, the study seeks to investigate the viability of concepts that will provide quality, continuity and smooth transition from pre-prep education to primary school while remaining true to a free early childhood educational philosophy. Theories of prominent educators, psychologists and sociologists, current overseas research and practise, as well as guidelines contained in developmentally appropriate publications, were used as foundations and substantiations for the concept of a structured learning component through which social skills, cognitive skills and internalised learning are developed. This is seen to enable the incorporation of continuity of learning into early schooling and beyond. Play remains the medium of the child's learning experiences. The research established that a structured learning component can be valuable provided it is carried out by experienced professionals. A survey of community opinion indicated that such a component can be beneficial to future learning. Literature across the ideological continuum as surveyed, and most authors advocated the need for some structure in the early childhood curriculum.