Faculty of Education - Theses
Permanent URI for this collection
Search Results
1 - 10 of 17
-
ItemThe politics of curriculum( 1999)This thesis seeks to document the development, establishment and subsequent demise of Victoria's first independent regulatory body of senior secondary curriculum and assessment, the Victorian Institute of Secondary Education. Analysis of the origins of VISE helps reveal the implicit social conflicts at work within the senior secondary curriculum. The thesis investigates the response of policy makers to the shift in senior secondary education from an 'elite' system to a 'mass' system in light of this conflict. The thesis argues that these responses in general, and VISE's in particular, while significantly expanding school control over the curriculum and pedagogical autonomy, failed to moderate social patterns of success and failure by not challenging the implicit rationale behind the curriculum hierarchy - the needs of the university for selection - and by failing to base curriculum policy on a wider understanding of the origins of such patterns.
-
ItemCurricula skills valued by parents of students attending special developmental schools( 1999)This study was undertaken to investigate the values placed on specific curricula skills by parents of intellectually disabled children. The study also examined the relationship between these values and selected background variables. In addition, this study identified the parental preferred length of time that should be spent on particular skills each week in the educational programs of their children. A two part questionnaire was used to collect the data. It consisted of items relating to the background characteristics of the respondents and curriculum items that parents of children with intellectual disabilities were asked to rate. Eighty-six parents in the Northern Metropolitan Region of Victoria provided data for this study. Space was provided for parents to indicate other skills which they felt would be important for their children to learn. Items were spread across four curricula domains: functional life, academic, social/friendship and 'other' skills. T-tests and analysis of variance were employed to determine the significance of differences between means of ratings on the variables. Several findings emerged from the study. Parents were found to prefer independent functional life skills and integrating social/friendship skills throughout their child's school life, while academic skills were consistently rated last. Consistent with these ratings was the further observation that self-help or independent living skills, communication and social skills, were categories highly valued by parents. Significant difference was found related to the age and gender of the children of parents making the ratings. No significant differences were identified for parent age or parent educational level. Independent functional life skills were rated higher for older children, particularly for boys while integrating social/friendship skills rated higher for older girls than for older boys. Recommendations for parent involvement in curriculum decision-making are included.
-
ItemBringing children to school, bringing schools to children : partnerships and perceptions of change in ethnic minority education in Vietnam( 1998)This research study examines the nature of curriculum development and change currently taking place in the area of ethnic minority education in Vietnam. The Multigrade and Bilingual Education Project, a UNICEF and World Bank funded initiative administered by the Vietnamese Ministry of Education and Training. aims to provide Universal Primary Education for children from Vietnam's 53 ethnic minority groups. Teacher training, the professional development of teachers, and the design of specialised curriculum for use in Multigrade schools are major funding priorities. Since 1991, the Multigrade and Bilingual Education Project has vastly increased ethnic minority children's school participation rates, has expanded its scope country wide, and has committed extensive resources towards the professional upgrading of teachers. Through the development of a series of teacher training modules, the Project has devised pedagogical structures for the introduction of localised curriculum. and appropriate methodology and resources for the teaching of ethnic minority language and culture. It has also actively encouraged a renovation of teaching methods to incorporate active learning and mixed ability grouping within Multigrade classrooms. These changes are a significant departure from past practices, and have been undertaken using collaborative structures not previously explored in the Vietnamese educational context. Given that these curriculum initiatives mark a distinct departure from the hitherto highly centralised and teacher-centred Vietnamese National Curriculum, deeper investigation of this phenomenon is needed. This research focuses on perceptions of educational change, as observed by a broad range of key players in the Multigrade and Bilingual Education Project. The researcher, experienced in teaching in multicultural settings in Melbourne, became interested in exploring the innovative nature of this Project when he was contracted by UNICEF to assist with the development of teacher development modules in Vietnam in 1995 and 1996. The research study draws on data gathered through surveys. document analysis and semi-structured interviews, and explores factors perceived as assisting or impeding the provision of a quality education to Vietnam's ethnic minority children. The nature of partnerships in fostering educational change, how this can be achieved in difficult circumstances, and the role of outside facilitators in this process are also examined.
-
ItemImpact of changes in Victorian government policies on the provision of schooling for primary school students with disturbing behaviour( 1998)The purpose of this study is to investigate the provision of schooling in Victoria, for children with problems arising from disturbing behaviour in regular schools. It is these students who have difficulty learning, and cause problems for peers and teachers. This problem has attracted more attention in recent decades than ever before as educators and parents seek solutions for these students. The impact of changes in government policies in Victoria, especially the introduction of the Schools of the Future Program, on students with disturbing behaviour is examined, together with effective means of supporting these students, their teachers and parents. The investigator defines disturbing behaviour and how it has been addressed in schools, particularly in Victoria. She examines the Schools of the Future Program, particularly Global Budgeting and its impact on school policies and programs, focussing on the effect of these provisions in schooling for students with disturbing behaviour. The investigator has conducted a study of school principals in the area centred on Ballarat in order to examine their reactions to recent government education policy changes, and their effects on the schooling for such students. She discusses the implications of these changes for students with disturbing behaviour, including the most recent societal changes involving the youth of today, for example, the State Government initiatives addressing Drugs and Youth Suicide which have impacted on support and resourcing to schools, across the state.
-
ItemReturning home : the cross-cultural education of Australian missionaries from Latin America( 1998)The purpose of this study is to investigate the experiences of Australian missionaries returning from Latin America and relate these to the training provided by the mission organisations that sent them. This thesis focuses on the issues related to culture adjustment and the pattern of instruction used by mission organisations to keep missionaries psychologically, spiritually, physically and socially whole throughout the international cycle. The study includes an examination of pre-departure, on-field and post return education strategies used to create smooth cross-cultural transitions and successful re-entry into the Australian culture from Latin America. Data was collected from both mission organisations and missionaries and the different interpretations of training needs were examined. Qualitative methodology has been used in this study because reverse culture shock encompasses underlying human cognitive elements and thought processes that affect behaviour and communication. Evidence from the study indicated that there are no specific, formal education programs developed by the mission organisation to deal with the problems associated with re-entry. This thesis recommends that the mission organisations involved in this study need to exercise a duty of care towards their missionaries and to drastically overhaul their cross-cultural education programs.
-
ItemCombining intervention strategies when working with hearing-impaired mainstream students( 1998)Seven children with mild to moderate hearing impairment were selected for a language support pilot which provided support from an Itinerant Teacher of the Deaf in their mainstream classroom and in a withdrawal situation with two or three other children with hearing impairment. The withdrawal situation provided the children with a quieter learning environment, more opportunities to interact in spoken English with an adult and peers, and a positive atmosphere for promoting the use of hearing aids. This study looked for change in receptive and expressive language and improved mainstream classroom involvement of these seven children as a result of this alternative provision of support. This study found that a combination of the pull-in and pull-out models of service to mainstreamed students with mild to moderate hearing impairment can achieve receptive language growth above the norms expected for hearing children within six months. Expressively, six of the seven children showed a higher percentage of analyzable statements per forty utterances after six months' intervention. Six of the children were perceived by their teachers to have improved classroom involvement. Parents of six of the children perceived a greater involvement in family interactions.
-
ItemCooperative learning : a viable teaching strategy for gifted students in heterogeneous classrooms?( 1998)In recent years, there has been a strong movement towards educational restructuring and reform. Cooperative learning is one instructional strategy which many supporters see as central to the goals of the reform movement. While these cooperative learning methods hold promise for many students, the research is concentrated on the average and low-ability students. Its impact on the gifted students remains inadequately assessed. The problem escalates when many educators view cooperative learning as a panacea to address the difficulties brought about by educational reform, such as teaching a class with mixed academic abilities. In addition, cooperative learning has also been used to justify the move to reduce differentiated programmes for the gifted population. This study addresses the controversy regarding the use of cooperative learning with the gifted students in a heterogeneous classroom. This is done by comparing gifted students learning cooperatively with those learning individually in a typical regular classroom. Viability of the teaching method is determined by investigating which learning environment better caters to the learning as well as affective needs of the gifted and talented students with the use of achievement tests and attitude measures. 19 gifted students were randomly assigned to a cooperative and individualistic learning condition. The students participated in a six X 55-minute instructional course based on social studies. The cooperative learning model used in this study was the Jigsaw method. The results indicate that cooperative learning experiences promoted higher achievement and the use of higher-order thinking skills among the gifted students. The results also suggest that the gifted students in a heterogeneous class felt more supported and accepted by their peers and teachers in the cooperative condition. It is concluded that cooperative learning can be beneficial to gifted students in a heterogeneous classroom if steps are taken to ensure that the students are suitably challenged. Well-trained teachers, appropriate structuring of the groups and differentiating the curriculum to suit the needs of the gifted students are identified as some of the factors crucial to the success of the cooperative learning strategy.
-
ItemGirls & post school achievement : discourse, meaning & subjectivity( 1998)In an overall sense the concern of my research is the question of gender. It is concerned with girls' engagement with the discursive fields which make up their lives, their acquisition of meaning and formation of subjectivity. Specifically, my research is concerned with the role of discourse in girls' acquisition of meaning about gender, achievement and success, and the ways in which teachers can develop strategies to support girls to negotiate the complex and contradictory discourses which surround them. As a poststructuralist feminist researcher I assume a keen awareness of the semiotic, discursive dimension of the social and from such a perspective consider the question of gender in relation to girls' education and post school achievement and career success. Through an emphasis on the discourses and texts which make up schools and educational practices, such a perspective makes relevant the emotional, psychic and physical embeddedness of girls in the discursively constituted categories to which they belong. The study undertaken is a critical engagement with one of the discourses shaping girls' identities. It draws on data gathered from a focused analysis of a selection of four celebratory feminist texts. The complex and contradictory nature of the meanings within the texts are examined, and the potential of this genre of feminist discourses to remake meanings and challenge the gender order of society is explored. My own personal and professional biography and the focus of the literature review have fashioned the specific questions I posed.
-
ItemAcceleration of gifted students: a study of the opinions of teachers and parents( 1998)The purpose of the study was to investigate the opinions of teachers and parents on the educational acceleration of gifted students. Gifted education has a relatively short history in Australia, although the education of gifted and talented students in the USA has been an issue of strong interest since the early 1920s. Many topics continue to be vigorously debated including definitions, identification and assessment and appropriate educational and instructional approaches. One of the most contentious issues surrounds the use of acceleration procedures. A review of the literature revealed that despite positive evidence concerning the appropriateness and associated benefits of educational acceleration, it is not a popular or widely practised procedure for gifted students. A barrier to the wider acceptance of acceleration procedures would appear to be the general apprehensiveness or negative attitudes of some teachers and parents. A literature review indicated that most of the studies have focussed on the intellectual, educational and socio-emotional benefits of acceleration. Typically, gifted students have been assessed to determine the influence of educational acceleration on the growth and development of these skills and attributes. The opinions of teachers and parents who have had direct experience with acceleration have not been frequently investigated. The studies that have been undertaken have resulted in generally consistent findings. Teachers and parents were mainly concerned about possible deleterious socio-emotional consequences of acceleration. In this study, the opinions of teachers and parents were explored using a specially prepared questionnaire. Twenty-six teachers and 23 parents returned completed questionnaires. An item analysis of the questions indicated their general suitability for the purposes of the study. Analysis of the teachers' and parents' responses revealed no overall statistically significant difference in their opinions. Investigation of the responses of both groups of respondents on each of the 26 questions in the questionnaire resulted in only one statistically significant outcome. Further analyses of the data showed interesting similarities and differences in response trends and patterns of the teachers and parents. In general, teachers and parents held very similar opinions on acceleration. While both groups expressed positive views about certain aspects of acceleration, they also shared several negative opinions. Teachers were found to be more uncertain about the social and emotional/behavioural benefits of acceleration and were generally less supportive of acceleration than parents. These findings are in general agreement with the results of previous research. It was concluded that teachers would benefit from professional development programs on gifted education, especially the efficacy and positive benefits of educational acceleration.
-
ItemSetting standards: a comparison of two Rasch-Model methods( 1998)Standard setting is an important issue in education. This study has applied two Rasch model techniques, Angoffs sum of probability and Andrich's pairwise comparison, to set cutoff scores for a Tasmanian Year 9 Link Test at year 3, year 5 and year 8 level. The main focus of the study was to examine methods of setting cutoff scores in the context of the National Profiles. The study also aimed at examining the relative difficulty of two parts of the Link Test on Mathematics for Year 9 students in Tasmania. Standard setting issues were analysed in the light of criterion referenced assessment in terms of their purposes and implications in education and measurement. Review of previous standard setting methods was also done. The two methods applied in the study were Angoff's sum of probabilities and Andrich's pairwise comparison. Both are popular in the educational context for establishing cutoff scores and examining the difficulty levels of tests. The findings produced by the sum of probability method have shown that cutoff score at each level of part 1 was higher than that of part 2, so that part 2 of the Link Test was more difficult than part 1. It was consistent with the item estimates produced by the pairwise comparison method. The correlations were high and significant at 0.05 level. It was consistent to those findings by Andrich and Titmanis (1997). However, the correlations between item difficulty estimates established by the pairwise comparison and empirical data were low from 0.39. The study has shown the possibility of using the two Rasch model techniques, sum of probability and pairwise comparison to establish cutoff score and examine the relative difficulty of the tests. Pairwise comparison method could be used as a mean of checking the validity of the proposed standards. It was shown that further research in this field should be done.