Faculty of Education - Theses
Permanent URI for this collection
Search Results
1 - 10 of 19
-
ItemEthnocentricity in The school paper, 1896-1939( 1985)This thesis explores the nature of the ethnocentric focus of the School paper from its inception in 1896 to the commencement of World War II in 1939. Although the School Paper was first published in response to an expressed government request that colonial reading material be provided to Victorian pupils, School papers from 1896 to 1907 are dominated by a powerful British influence extending to moral, economic, patriotic and military spheres. The monarchy is the imperial focus. Although proud Australian nationalism is a gradual development, there is already consciousness of a distinct, unique social and environmental milieu. The period is marked by profound respect for Britain, a sense of kinship with America and tolerance for the Arab world; 'coloured' races, including Australian Aborigines, are depicted as being inferior to whites. The years 1908 to the commencement of World War I in 1914 are marked by the strength of the Empire Movement; imperialist propaganda was actively disseminated by the School paper. There is growing awareness of Australia as native land, with its own individual identity, yet still with a filial link to Britain. The School paper. reflects the preparation of children for the coming war. America is looked on with favour and Germany is regarded with some reservation. Coloured races continue to be scorned, except for the Australian Aborigines who, at this time, are accorded a significant degree of respect and sympathy. Australian nationalism was crystallised during the war years from 1915 to 1918, and the Anzac legend became enshrined, assisted by School Paper promotion. Patriotism was both engendered and used by the School paper to raise money for the war effort. From this period there is a decline in the strength of British focus in the School Paper and a shift to imperialism. Although attitudes to white races are generally tolerant, with much forbearance towards Turkish and German enemies, there is coolness towards America, a general disregard of Australian Aborigines, and a persistence of prejudice towards other 'coloured' races. The post-war decade, 1919-1929, marks a flowering of Australian nationalism, with School Papers cultivating pride in Australian literature, art, history, and sporting heroes. Anzac Day and Armistice Day commemorative issues recount for new generations the honour that Australia achieved in war. Although the imperial theme is promoted less aggressively, Australia is still depicted as daughter of the Mother Country, and the Royal Family is regularly presented as both head and symbol of the Empire. Tolerance is extended to Europeans, Irish and Americans, but is witheld from Maoris, American Indians, Africans and Australian Aborigines. School Papers during the Depression years from 1929 to the commencement of World War II reflect a diminution of active Australian nationalism and of British martial content. Concomitantly, imperial sisterhood and internationalism are fostered. The pacifist tone of School Papers of this time sits oddly with the continued promotion of Anzac Day and Armistice Day. Contradictory School Papers messages at this time validate respect and tolerance for other races, yet show quite vicious intolerance of non-whites, including Australian Aborigines. By 1939 the School Papers demonstrate a continued pride in British ethnocentricity, superimposed on which is an Australian nationalism that waxes and wanes in intensity. There is tolerance of a broader range of races, but there remains a cruel arrogance towards the alleged inferiority of 'coloured' peoples; the School Papers was a powerful force in the transmission of these attitudes.
-
ItemTransforming policy into practice : the implementation of the Curriculum and Standards Framework in primary schools in Victoria( 1997)This thesis examines individual school use of a newly introduced curriculum policy, the Curriculum and Standards Framework (CSF). Its purpose was to explore how a central policy impacted on individual schools and the processes that occurred within the school to transform CSF policy into classroom practice. It examines the way knowledge relating to CSF policy and other knowledge was transferred and used within schools and the factors that affected this process. The context in which this innovation occurred was examined before considering the determinants and outcomes of policy use. Recent knowledge utilisation theory in the area of policy innovation was used to refine ideas further. It was argued that a major determinant of CSF use was the characteristics of the CSF itself. From this a tentative three level conceptual model for CSF policy use was constructed. Variation in. use, it was reasoned, depended on local capacity to utilise curriculum knowledge. These arguments formed the basis of the research questions. A multiple case study approach was used to determine both the general pattern for CSF use and variations in use. An exploratory approach, gaining data from many sources within each of the sites over time, was utilised. Analysis of the data showed that the conceptual model was appropriate and a single factor, defined as "culture of change", accounted for most of the variation between sites. This factor was a conglomerate of sub-factors concerning structures, knowledge, processes and capabilities within individual school sites. In line with other similar studies, the thesis demonstrated the importance of local factors in policy use. The thesis goes further than other studies of this type by identifying the particular structures, practices and expertise that resulted in informed curriculum policy implementation through effective knowledge utilisation. In particular, the study demonstrated the importance of intensive structured professional interaction to maximise knowledge utilisation.
-
ItemMauritius and inclusion : a study of teachers' attitudes toward the inclusion of students with special needs in regular primary schools( 2006)This study was undertaken to investigate the attitudes of regular education teachers toward the inclusion of students with Special Needs in regular education classrooms in Mauritius. In the context of Ajzen's (1991) Theory of Planned Behaviour, a survey and case studies were undertaken in Mauritius. The data was used to identify teachers' attitudes, to explore teachers' intentions and to investigate teachers' inclusive classroom practices in regards to the inclusion of students with Special Needs in their classrooms. A three-part self-completion questionnaire was used to collect the data. Part 1, the STATIC-MR scale, consisted of an expanded version of Cochran's (1997) Scale of Teachers' Attitudes Toward Inclusive Classrooms. Part 2 collected background information about teachers. Part 3 gathered data regarding teacher training and professional development. In addition, the survey instrument included an open-ended question, which required respondents to comment on inclusion in Mauritius. Six hundred and seven regular education teachers from a non-proportionate, stratified sample of 62 primary schools took part in the survey and follow-up case studies of eleven teachers were carried out. SPSS and QUEST software were utilised to analyse the data. Results yielded high reliability for the STATIC-MR scale, (Cronbach alpha: .89) and each individual item had an alpha value above .88. Using a one-parameter Rasch model rating scale analysis, four bands of attitudes were identified. In the first band, 4.9% of the teachers were found to be very agreeable with inclusion. In the second band, 35% were found to be agreeable with inclusion. In the third band, 51.7% were not so agreeable with inclusion because certain conditions were not present; yet teachers in this band thought that students with Special Needs should not be placed in special schools. The fourth band revealed that 8.4% were opposed to inclusion. Responses to the open-ended question: 'What suggestions would you like to make about the inclusion of students with Special Needs in regular education classrooms in Mauritius?' indicated that teachers greatest concerns were logistical in nature (32.8%). Logistical concerns were about large class sizes, lack of space and time, unavailability of specialist support and lack of parent support. Teachers also had professional concerns (20.5%), philosophical concerns (11.3%), concern related to the advantages to the student with Special Needs (4%), concerns related to the disadvantages to students with and/or without Special Needs (7.5%). Other teachers expressed the need for parent involvement (2%), or favoured integration rather than inclusion (7%) or were categorically opposed to inclusion without a specified reason (15%). Descriptive analyses identified differences in attitudes between teachers in different school sectors, teachers of different grades, teachers with different class sizes, and teachers with different training and qualifications. The 572 respondents, teachers of 8,560 students, reported 3135 students with Special Needs (16.3%) in their classes. They identified students having health or physical differences (9 %), students with behaviour differences (24 %), students with learning differences (63%), and students with other differences (4%). Several major findings emerged from the study. The majority of teachers surveyed indicated that they had no Special Education Qualifications (93%), no in-service training related to inclusion or disability (91%), and yet were willing to be trained for inclusion (77%). Correlation and regression analyses revealed a strong correlation between teachers' intentions (willingness to be trained) and their attitude toward inclusion. Several background variables of teachers correlated with teachers' attitudes and with teachers' intentions. Primarily, class size appeared to have some effect on teachers' attitudes and teachers' experience with inclusion and in-service training an effect on teachers' intentions. Follow-up case studies of the eleven teachers explored the modifications and adaptations teachers made to accommodate students with Special Needs in their classes. Teachers' reports of modifications allowed for them to be placed along a spectrum ranging from 'preventive' to 'intervene traditionally' to 'traditional', similar to Stanovich and Jordan's (1998) spectrum. Results of the interviews with the eleven teachers indicated a strong association between teachers' attitudes and their behaviours. The more positive the teachers' attitudes, the more likely they were to address the needs of students in their classes. This study provided discussion of the implications of the findings and made recommendations for improving teachers' attitudes toward the inclusion of students with Special Needs in Mauritius.
-
ItemUsing action methods in health education / Anna Shadbolt( 1995)This study examines the usefulness of action methods for the teaching of health education to children. A model for the training of teachers in the use of these methods was developed, implemented and evaluated. The literature on the philosophy and methodology of psychodrama, a creation of J.L. Moreno, is reviewed highlighting some reported uses of the psychodramatic method with children. The application of action methods to the school environment is considered with a particular emphasis on its usefulness for the teaching of personal development and human relations. Limitations of its use in the classroom are also considered. A survey of local primary schools found that the health education taught is missing areas of the curriculum that tend to be sensitive and emotionally charged, mostly in the area of human relations. Lack of specialised training and resources are put forward as factors contributing to the omission of major portions of the health education curriculum in the schools. Appropriate professional training and support networks in these specialised areas of teaching are needed. Training in the use of action methods is one intervention that will help teachers in health education delivery. A two-part training program in action methods was delivered to teachers in the local area. It included a series of experiential workshops and individualised follow-up in the classrooms of workshop participants. The teachers and children found action methods to be useful classroom strategies for learning about health and human relations. The training structure was useful for assessing the individual training needs of teachers and children. The training program was found to be too short and hence lacked the necessary intensity for adequate skill acquisition. The follow-up component was highly effective. The indications of these findings for teacher training are discussed emphasising the importance of maintaining a balanced view of the place of action methods as only one teaching strategy, albeit a very effective and powerful one. Health education teaching is complex. Action methods were found to be useful for helping teachers with the many challenges that this curriculum area presents when delivered in the primary school classroom.
-
ItemA comparative study of the social competence of young children in junior primary within multiage and single grade classrooms( 1997)The purpose of this study was to compare the social competence of young children in their first years of school between two different classroom structures, multiage classrooms and single grade classrooms, during their first years of school. The study involved seventy-six students randomly selected from junior sections of four state schools from metropolitan Melbourne. Schools were identified as being multiaged or single grade using a set criteria standard and were selected following an initial telephone interview with the principal from each school. The four schools were matched on socioeconomic status and class size. Children's social competence was assessed using the Social Skills Rating Scale (SSRS), (Gresham Elliot, 1990). Questionnaires were completed by both parents and teachers. The indicators of social competence were self-control, assertiveness, and cooperation. Behaviour problems and academic competence domains were also rated by teachers as part of the SSRS. Behaviour problems were also rated by parents. An additional questionnaire was completed by teachers in regard to their educational qualifications, teaching experience and classroom experiences. Background information regarding the children's experiences prior to commencing school was collected by an additional questionnaire to parents. Children's social competence, as assessed by teachers, was found to be significantly higher in the multiage classroom structure. In addition, teachers indicated that children had significantly fewer behaviour problems. within multiage classrooms. Within some of the social, behavioural and academic domains, a significant difference scored by teachers was also found in regard to gender and girls were assessed by teachers as possessing higher levels of social competence than boys in the total teacher scores in the domain of self-control and cooperative skills. These outcomes are discussed in terms of their significance for education policy makers, teachers, parents and school communities who are investigating classroom structures, learning and social competence for children.
-
ItemThe initial implementation of a mandated assessment project( 1995)During 1994 the Directorate of School Education decided to implement a statewide assessment project aimed at primary aged students. Under the guidance of the Board of Studies, this project was announced and it was anticipated that all Victorian State Primary schools would participate in the project in 1995. This study is a record of how the staff at one State Primary School reacted to the implementation of this mandated assessment project. It draws upon literature on teacher change and from the British National Curriculum to identify issues relating to the Victorian context. Using teacher concerns as a focus this study explores the affective reaction of the teachers in the study and the extent to which they accommodated or rejected the change. It explores to what extent teacher interpretations of change are affected by various sources of information. And whether these sources impacted upon the acceptance or rejection of the Learning Assessment Project. A number of issues that need to be taken into consideration when implementing educational change were identified. It also focuses on Hall and Loucks (1978) theory of the Stages of Concern, identifying that in the case of mandated change, teachers concerns do not follow the same pattern as those identified by Hall and Loucks.
-
ItemChildren's adjustment to the first year of school( 1994)The aim of this study was to determine whether children's adjustment to the first year of school was influenced by the number of transition activities conducted by schools. The study was undertaken in a number of state-run primary schools in the Melbourne Metropolitan Region and comprised two stages of inquiry. Stage 1 of the study involved 100 randomly selected schools in a telephone survey to identify the type and number of transition activities conducted by schools. This stage provided essential background information for the selection of schools for the second stage of the study since no documented accounts of the type and number of transition programs conducted by Melbourne or Victorian schools could be located. Results of this preliminary study revealed considerable variety in the type and number of transition activities reported by schools prior to, and following, the commencement of school, involving children, parents, families, and collaboration between staff at the school and preschool levels. Stage 2 of the study involved 203 children from four metropolitan schools. The schools were selected on the basis of the number of transition activities they conducted. Children's adjustment to school was measured after eight weeks of schooling using the Social Skills Rating System. Forms were completed by teachers and parents, and children's adjustment was rated in the domains of social skills, behaviour, and academic competence. Additional background information was sought from parents regarding the child's family, previous preschool experience and whether or not the child commenced school with a familiar playmate. The results indicate statistically significant associations between children's adjustment to the first year of school and numbers of transition activities conducted by schools. In addition, there were significant associations between adjustment and children's preschool experiences, as well as the presence of a familiar playmate in the same class.
-
ItemRevision of the State primary school curriculum in Victoria, 1928-34: its social and educational context( 1981)In the years 1928-34, educational leaders in Victoria worked towards a comprehensive revision of the State elementary school curriculum, a process which culminated in the publication of the General Course of Study for Elementary Schools, 1934. During these years the concept of curriculum expanded. It came to include not only the content of the printed courses of study, but also expressions of belief regarding the place of the school in society, ideas related to child development and learning theory, and to the everyday events and activities which took place in schools. Educationists saw in Australia's response to World War I, her commitment to the concept of Empire, and the increase in Australian nationalistic feeling, a set of social factors which helped shape the view that the school should promote the ideal of social unification. Never precisely defined, social unification was seen to involve the production of intelligent citizens who could assist the development of a better society. Education was thus seen to be a major vehicle for instilling the "spirit of service" within children. Educationists devoted increasing attention to an identification of societal changes as they perceived them. Further, they sought to define the implications of these changes for the elementary school curriculum. The depression of the early 1930's reinforced the view that the school and its curriculum should provide pupils with the means to affect the future of society. The concept of democracy, too, was an important factor contributing to an expanded view of curriculum. Closely associated with democracy were the notions of individuality and socialisation, each of which was seen to be an important aim of educational endeavour. Despite problems of definition, the concept of democracy bolstered the view that the school and therefore its curriculum should be a means of social unification. Perceptions of the prevailing social situation inevitably led to an identification of the shortcomings of present educational theory and practice. An increasing number of Victorian educationists took the opportunity to experience, at first-hand, educational practice in the U.S.A. and Europe, with the result that access to the writings and ideas of overseas educationists was facilitated, and that the eclectic approach which typified Victorian educational developments was enhanced. A comprehensive, yet ambiguous set of aims for the Victorian elementary school was stated. It reflected the view that the school was an important socialising agent within society. Further, a set of principles for curriculum revision was identified. Derived from the English Hadow Report, it indicated the growing awareness that the discipline of psychology was crucial for the design of an appropriate curriculum for Victoria's school children. Despite the fact that an expanded view of the curriculum had emerged, imprecision of language, incomplete understandings and misinterpretations of ideas or practice led to conflicting ideas and ambiguity. In addition, within Victoria's centralised education system, there were a number of constraints which affected the outcomes of the curriculum revision movement. The 1934 Course of Study reflected these constraints. It nevertheless did indicate that significant advances in educational thought had taken place.
-
ItemThe impact of positions of leadership in Catholic primary schools( 1997)This research emanated from an interest that was developed in leadership roles and how these have impacted on Victorian Catholic Primary Schools, especially in the North Central Zone. Questions that were used as the main focus for this study were: How does the role of the Catholic Primary Principal impact on Positions of Leadership? And Does the existence of Positions of Leadership make Catholic Primary Schools more effective? In order to find the answers to these questions both quantitative and qualitative research was undertaken in the form of a Case Study. The study involved gathering data from Principals, teachers with Positions of Leadership and teachers without Positions of Leadership in the North Central Zone. The data for this research came from collated responses in the form of questionnaires from eighteen schools and transcripts of interviews from six people at two schools within the zone. Whilst writings from a variety of sources have been used to clarify and add meaning to this research, several writers were used as a basis for the study including; Bolman and Deal (1991), Fullan (1991), Fullan and Stiegelbauer (1991), Hargreaves (1994) and Little and McLaughlin (c1993). This research highlighted several areas that need to be addressed if Positions of Leadership are to have a positive impact on Victorian Catholic Primary Schools. 1) Schools need to incorporate ongoing review of all aspects of school operations through the School Development Plan. In particular, this could seek to ensure that the school is operating effectively both administratively and educationally. 2) The role of principals should not be underestimated as they have responsibility for all aspects of the running of the school. The leadership style used by the principal will directly impact on the effectiveness of Positions of Leadership operating within the school. It is only through the use of a collaborative style of leadership that POLs will be able to have maximum effect. 3) Personnel chosen for Positions of Leadership need to be carefully screened ensuring that they have not only an enthusiasm and understanding of the area for which they will have responsibility but that their disposition allows for open communication.
-
ItemCan the incorporation of a structured pre-primary curriculum improve primary scholastic performance?( 1996)Primary and secondary educational reforms seeking quality and accountability are placing top-down pressure on early childhood education to become more defined and assessable in preparation for future learning. State and Federal government policies advocate set curriculum with definable results. Such trends are also observed overseas. The aim is for early childhood education to be more relevant to the rest of the child's learning and to the demands of the time. A large body of professionals within early childhood education view this as an intrusive, restrictive and regressive approach which is inconsistent with what years of research have taught us about early childhood education. They maintain that early childhood education is a stage in its own right and does not need to be altered to match another. Their main view is that each child learns individually to full potential via firsthand experiences through play under the guidance of a qualified educarer. Frameworks, and curricular continuity are seen as restrictions of such freedom. Generally accepting this premise, the study seeks to investigate the viability of concepts that will provide quality, continuity and smooth transition from pre-prep education to primary school while remaining true to a free early childhood educational philosophy. Theories of prominent educators, psychologists and sociologists, current overseas research and practise, as well as guidelines contained in developmentally appropriate publications, were used as foundations and substantiations for the concept of a structured learning component through which social skills, cognitive skills and internalised learning are developed. This is seen to enable the incorporation of continuity of learning into early schooling and beyond. Play remains the medium of the child's learning experiences. The research established that a structured learning component can be valuable provided it is carried out by experienced professionals. A survey of community opinion indicated that such a component can be beneficial to future learning. Literature across the ideological continuum as surveyed, and most authors advocated the need for some structure in the early childhood curriculum.