Faculty of Education - Theses
Permanent URI for this collection
Search Results
1 - 8 of 8
-
ItemThe pedagogy of engagement: classroom management vs. facilitating learning( 2019)This thesis explored the way upper primary teachers think about student engagement and how they operationalise the concept within their classrooms. Student engagement has been frequently linked to academic success, and improving the engagement of students continues to be a priority for policy makers and practitioners alike. Despite an abundance of research, it remains questionable whether researcher conceptions of student engagement adequately represent the way teachers experience the concept. Teachers' perspectives on student engagement and their engagement-related practices were investigated over two studies using an exploratory sequential mixed methods design. In Study One, in-depth interviews were conducted with 16 teachers to explore their beliefs about student engagement in learning. Teachers described six qualitatively different forms of engagement and disengagement, as well as a complex process for facilitating student engagement within lessons. A typology of engagement and a pedagogical framework for engaging students were proposed based on the findings. Study Two sought to test the validity of the typology as a representation of teachers' descriptions of student engagement and its usefulness in coding teachers' engagement-related interactions within observed lessons. Four teachers were interviewed and four lessons observations for each teacher were conducted. In addition, 72 students within those classrooms were surveyed to explore their perceptions of aspects of the learning environment, including their understanding of teacher expectations for student engagement. Qualitative analysis of interview and observation data revealed that teachers varied in their expectations for student engagement within lessons, their views on the role of peers in student engagement, and in the frequency with which they intervened within lessons to facilitate different forms of student engagement. Quantitative analysis of survey data suggest that students in different classrooms perceive different expectations for how they will engage in learning experiences. A model is proposed for thinking about the pedagogy of student engagement, providing an alternative vantage point from which to explore the concept, one that is grounded in the real-life experiences of teachers facing the ongoing challenge of engaging students in classroom learning experiences.
-
ItemContemplative practitioners, becoming teachers: a study of the implications of contemplative practices for teacher professional becoming( 2019)This thesis explores the implications of contemplative practices for beginning teachers, focusing on issues of identity, being and becoming. In the current neoliberal context, teaching is primarily conceived in terms of decontextualised standards of practice. As a result of this, the question of the ‘who’ of the teacher remains neglected. Contemplative practices, as practices of awareness and self-inquiry, are taken as an avenue to re-open questions of the teacher-self. The purpose of this inquiry is to bring further theoretical clarity and empirical grounding to scholarship regarding contemplative practices and the teacher. It extends existing work by presenting a rich theorisation of the teacher-self, and by exploring contemplative practices defined inclusively, beyond the current preoccupation with mindfulness. The study was guided by the question: What are the implications of contemplative practices for teacher professional becoming? To respond to the research question an exploratory, qualitative, multiple case-study was conducted, informed by Heidegger’s hermeneutic phenomenology, Schatzki’s theory of social practices, and aspects of Buddhist philosophy. Seven beginning teachers with an existing commitment to contemplative practice were recruited and participated in interviews, metaphoric drawing, school-based fieldwork, and shared researcher-participant meditation over the period of one year. Study participants engaged in a range of contemplative practices, which were associated with a variety of altered experiences of time, space, self and world. These practices and experiences were woven into forms of identity work, via which participants imagined themselves as teachers in a context characterised by uncertainty and in-betweenness (theorised here as liminality). Participants identified various forms of overlap, harmony, and friction between the worlds of teaching and contemplative practices. Beyond being a technique of self-care, contemplative practices played both a constructive and deconstructive role with respect to teacher identity. As constructive, contemplative practices inflected the purposes of teaching, and also grounded the cultivation of virtues (including calm, compassion and curiosity). As deconstructive, contemplative practices of self-inquiry facilitated a loosening of the habitual aspects of the self, which I conceive as un-becoming. This work culminated in the phenomenon of presence—an aware, responsive and connected mode of being—which, at times, was inhibited by the social and institutional structures of education. The interpretation of the empirical material shows how contemplative practices have significant implications for beginning teacher identity and practice. They operate as nodes of stability within the liminal spaces of teacher professional becoming. However, paradoxically, they emphasise that the un-making of the teacher-self may be just as important as the making of the teacher-self, captured in the notion of professional-becoming-as-un-becoming. Overall, the findings suggest that educational policymakers and school leaders assessing the value of mindfulness need to be aware of the broader web of practices to which it is historically and philosophically related. The findings also suggest substantial opportunities for the integration of aspects of contemplative practice, as supporting forms of reflection and radical reflexivity, into teacher education and professional development. However, there remain a range complex issues which need to be addressed in doing so.
-
ItemInvestigating teachers’ knowledge, practice and change following an oral language professional learning program( 2018)Language and literacy are increasingly topics of educational and public health interest, and research suggests that these skills are significantly impacted by early educational experiences. Crucially, there is wide agreement that teaching quality is a key determinant of student achievement. In a series of three studies, the knowledge and classroom practices of early years’ teachers, and teachers’ self-perceived and measured changes that occurred during and following a sustained oral language professional learning program were explored. These investigations were informed by Desimone’s (2009) model of professional development and Hoy and Miskel’s social system model for schools (2008). In Study 1, the knowledge of language constructs and associated self-rated ability of 78 Victorian teachers was measured. Consistent with a number of earlier Australian and international studies, teachers’ explicit and implicit knowledge of basic linguistic constructs was limited and highly variable. Despite rating their skills and knowledge as either moderate or very good, the collective knowledge of this cohort was found to be limited and variable. A statistically significant correlation was found between total self-rated ability and experience teaching the early years of primary school, but no relationship was found between self-rated ability and overall performance on knowledge items, indicating that participants’ knowledge was not well calibrated. In Study 2, the feasibility of a novel approach to collecting teacher talk data was investigated, as was the application of an existing framework to describe talk. This approach was then applied to measure change in 12 teachers’ talk over the course of the professional learning program. Over the course of the professional learning program teachers used proportionately more talk that explained strategies that students could use to support their language and literacy learning, and this increase was sustained 12 months later. The aim of Study 3 was to describe the observed and self-perceived changes in knowledge, practice and beliefs of teachers who participated in the professional learning program, and whether change was adequately accounted for by current models of professional development. In three case studies it was illustrated that despite participating in the same sustained professional learning program, teachers’ growth in knowledge was variable. Change in self-rated ability was influenced by observed student outcomes (which teachers attributed to change in their practice). In one case, professional growth was restricted by factors within the school environment. Conclusions drawn from this body of research are that (i) oral language is rarely disaggregated from early literacy and lacks visibility in the early years of primary school, (ii) teachers’ knowledge of language and literacy is variable, often limited and poorly calibrated, and (iii) the construct of teacher cognition and theoretical models of teacher practice change can and should inform the design and implementation of professional learning.
-
ItemMy Italian kindergarten: an investigation of preschool language teaching( 2016)While early natural second language acquisition often produces high levels of bilingual competence, second language learning in institutional settings is far less successful. One response has been to lower the starting age for second language instruction to preschool, but there has been limited research to date into pedagogy for language teaching tailored to early childhood education settings. This study takes an analytic autoethnographic approach to investigating teaching in a play-based bilingual program. Situated in an Italian-English kindergarten program in Melbourne, the study is an inquiry into microprocesses of second language teaching. The Bilingual Turn in education and second language research seeks to acknowledge multilingual realities, suggesting reconsideration of assumptions about language separation in education, recommending bilingual practices such as translanguaging and responsible code-switching, and proposing the adoption of Usage-Based Linguistics as a theory of second language development. This study examines records of enacted bilingual teaching using practitioner reflection, and theoretical resources drawn from the perspective of the Bilingual Turn. The project takes up two related facets of teacher language use, with one focus on English use and issues of language separation and alternation, and the other focus on Italian use and formulaic language in routines. The study finds teaching practices that maximise target language exposure may be a higher priority than language separation. On the other hand, while it may be valid to adopt intentionally bilingual teaching strategies in some settings, the learning context must be considered. Analysis of formulaic language use in routines identifies ‘scripted’ routines as a pedagogical strategy used to add frequency to opportunities for Italian language interaction in a manner compatible with a Usage-Based Linguistics approach to piecemeal repertoire building.
-
ItemCreative practice, value, and the teaching of art and design in higher education( 2014)Despite the current emphasis on creativity in education, the teaching of art and design in universities is an underresearched area of higher education. Those who teach within university art and design disciplines are most often artists and designers with their own active and vibrant creative practices. Yet the connection between the teaching of art and design and the creative practices of the artists and designers who teach in those programs is not well understood. This thesis is an attempt to articulate this area. Contemporary higher education, a space currently experiencing much change due to the force of economics and policy in Australia and internationally, is the contextual background for this research. Within this context, the academic disciplines of art and design and those who teach within them are considered in light of their creative practices as artists and designers, and the value of this practice. I began with the premise that there is value in the teaching of art and design, and from the creative practices of artists and designers who teach in these disciplines; therefore, this thesis focuses on articulating the nature of this value rather than arguing for its existence. To research this topic, a qualitative methodology was used, with Australian art and design academics as participants. Qualitative methods involving two phases included semistructured interviews, class observations, visual data, participant journals, and field notes. Value theory was the main theoretical lens used for analysis, in addition to theories of embodied and tacit knowledge, and creativity. Analysis highlighted that participants model and draw from creative practice in teaching of art and design, conceptualise research in a variety of ways, struggle to balance their two professional worlds of creative practice and teaching, and seek the support of university leadership. Value, value disconnects, and tensions became apparent. In addition, research highlighted that dual values are at play: those of participants and those of universities. The research found the value that artist/designer-academics contribute from their creative practices to the teaching of art and design is primarily instrumental in nature because it is a means towards obtaining something else: enabling and assisting students to create works of art and design. I argue that this value encompasses three key areas in the teaching of art/design: the modelling of professional art/design practice, the ability to draw from various creative practices, and the mentoring of art/design students. In addition, artist/designer-academics contribute value in the form of their creative practice to the research agendas and outputs of universities. Each of these areas is contingent upon support and leadership within universities. Recommendations outlined suggest a way forward. This thesis is based in the experiences, views, and voices of its participants: those with active art and design practices who teach in university art and design programs. It also takes into account the realities of contemporary higher education, disciplinary cultures, creative practice, and notions of value in articulating the nature of the value contributed from the creative practices of artists and designers to the teaching of art and design.
-
ItemAssessment of student problem-solving processes with interactive computer-based tasks( 2009)Problem solving is recognised as an important intellectual activity in schooling and beyond. In particular, generic problem-solving skills which transfer across learning areas are valued educational outcomes. The objective of this study was the design and evaluation of an online assessment system that provided diagnostic information on students' development of problem-solving competencies at upper primary and lower secondary school level. This resulted in the development of a methodology for collecting and interpreting problem-solving process data to assess important procedural aspects of problem solving. In this research study, existing assessment design and analysis methodologies were extended and applied to produce descriptions of problem-solving behaviour useful for both students and educators. The assessment system utilised recent advances in technology, assessment design and analysis, and problem-solving theory to guide the development of interactive computer-based tasks and to facilitate the interpretation of complex process data from student solution processes. Rules for interpreting computer-captured process data were empirically validated using qualitative verbal protocol analysis techniques. This study introduced a novel contribution to assessment design methodology called a temporal evidence map. This data transcription tool was designed for displaying and analysing concurrent sources of process data collected throughout task piloting exercises. Use of this tool culminated in the refinement of tasks and scoring rules, and informed development of additional tasks for the main data collection phase of the study. Following large-scale online data collection, the data were probabilistically modelled using Bayesian Inference Networks. A range of model evaluations were carried out to gauge aspects of assessment validity and reliability. Finally, the inferences generated via Bayesian modelling were used to produce diagnostic student profile reports suitable for informing instruction. Educators have much to gain from technology-based assessment systems underpinned by cognitively diagnostic models of cognition. In particular, supporting assessment inferences about procedural quality is well-aligned with 21st century skills in information-rich educational and vocational settings. This study provides diagnostic information to educators about how, and not just if, students solve problems.
-
ItemJourneys of adaptation of Chinese and Vietnamese international students to academic writing practices in higher education( 2007)The study reported in this thesis explores how Chinese and Vietnamese international students exercise personal agency and mediate their academic writing to adapt to disciplinary practices at an Australian university. It also examines academics' attitudes toward student writing. The study employs a trans-disciplinary framework for interpreting student writing practices and lecturers' views within the institutional structure. This framework has been developed by infusing a modified version of Lillis' heuristic for exploring students' meaning making in higher education with positioning theory. The study documents the complexities and multi-layered nature of the adaptation processes that the students go through in their attempts to mediate their academic writing. A prominent finding of the study indicates the emergence of three main patterns of adaptation, committed adaptation, surface adaptation and hybrid adaptation, that the students employ to gain access to their disciplinary writing practices. The students' process of adaptation arises from their intrinsic motivations to be successful in their courses and to participate in their disciplinary community. However, where they differ is in their internal struggle related to what they really value amongst the possible disciplinary writing requirements they adopt in constructing their texts. The findings of the study show that the students' journeys of adaptation appear to be much more complex than what is often described in the current literature as being largely related to language and cultural factors. The analysis or the students' practices shows that they exercise personal agency by drawing on various strategies to facilitate their understandings of disciplinary expectations. In particular, the students have transformed their own practices through seeking ways to contact their lecturers to deepen their understandings of the disciplinary expectations, ask for feedback on draft versions of writing assignments and go through the redrafting process. The students are quite successful in using different ways to increase their understandings of the disciplinary expectations and even find the process rewarding. This shows that contrary to popular belief, international students in this study are able to demonstrate initiative and problem-solving skills. They actively exercise their own power as students, which allows them to participate in their disciplinary written discourse. The findings also indicate that what is of paramount importance to students' success is the interaction and dialogues they establish with their lecturers. The students' varying practices in spelling out what is expected of them establish a case for the importance of individual factors of each student and that success or failure is likely to relate to the possession of certain dispositions, regardless of one's ethnic background. The positioning analysis of the four lecturers involved in the study shows that they appear to be aware of the needs of international students and are determined to accommodate them in many ways. There are however a number of mismatches in the display of disciplinary knowledge among the academics themselves and between the academics and the students. Yet, in the relevant literature, what challenges international students is often attributed to such factors as English language, study skills and cultural adaptation, which arise from international students themselves. The study reported in this thesis reveals that the inconsistency and subtlety of the lecturers' explanations of the academic expectations makes it more challenging for international students to make sense of what is required of them in specific disciplines. Even though the lecturers attempt to find ways to facilitate students' understandings of the conventions, there is little mutual transformation occurring in terms of negotiating different ways of constructing knowledge. The findings of the study give insights into ways that a dialogical pedagogic model for mutual adaptation can be developed between international students and academics rather than the onus being on exclusive adaptation from the students. The model offers concrete steps towards developing mutual relationships and changes of international students and staff to each other within the overarching institutional realities of the university. Such a dialogical model is put forward as a tool to enhance the education of international students in this increasingly internationalized environment.
-
ItemPolitics and prescription: an analysis of reading texts in Victorian government primary schools 1872-1970( 2007)For a period of almost one hundred years - from the 1872 Education Act until 1970 the Victorian Education Department prescribed the reading curriculum of children in government primary schools, using texts from Ireland and Britain, followed by three sets published by the Department. This thesis describes the procedures undertaken in the selection of these texts, and analyses their contents in the light of the educational thinking of the times and the prevailing political, social and economic conditions. The Irish Books of Lessons were components of a national system of education in Ireland designed to provide a non-denominational religious education for all children. Emphasis was placed on literary and moral values, Old Testament history and political economy. Transplanted to the colony of New South Wales, the Irish ideal of a common education failed because of intractable religious disputes between Anglican and Roman Catholic clerics. In Victoria there was discord in parliament relating to the contents of the books and the secular provision in the 1872 Education Act. In 1877 these books were replaced by the British Royal Readers, containing informational matter, English literature, and history related in terms of battles won and deeds of service for the Empire. Alterations to some items in the Royal Readers on the order of the Minister of Public Instruction because of their religious content caused further contention in parliament. Action from Roman Catholic sources succeeded in the banning of other books from schools on sectarian grounds, an outcome that had important ramifications for the administration of education in Victoria. Religious sensibilities were appeased with the Minister's decision to replace imported texts with the locally-produced School Papers in 1896. These monthly publications contained literature, informational items, stories for enjoyment and others of a moralistic bent. The Anglophile nature of the Royal Readers was maintained with material promoting loyalty to Britain and the Empire. Wide coverage of the Boer War and World War I was included. The inter-war period saw a growing emergence of an Australian identity in the School Papers, with fewer items calling for fealty to Crown and Empire, and local writers increasingly featured. The Victorian Readers, introduced in 1928, were the repository of the literature that remained an important element of the reading curriculum, much of it from Australian authors. Articles promoting peace in the reading material at this time foreshadowed the muted coverage of World War II in the School Papers. The new set of reading books published in the 1950s and 1960s continued in the literary style of their predecessors, with writing by current Australian and international authors. The capacity of the School Papers to respond to events as they unfolded enabled the readers to be kept informed of Australia's increasing involvement with Asia, the decline of old affiliations and the formation of new geopolitical alliances.