Melbourne Graduate School of Education - Theses
Permanent URI for this collection
Search Results
1 - 10 of 12
-
Item
-
ItemColin Campbell : religion and education, 1852-1872( 1974)This thesis investigates the role of Colin Campbell in the church-state struggles over education. Having found squatting precarious, and possessing a large capacity for public life, Campbell was pleased to become involved in colonial events on the conservative side. As democracy advanced and his worst fears proved groundless, he endeavoured to liberalize his outlook. A spokesman for pastoral tenants, he was held accountable for squatter misdeeds. Only at the district level and within his church, was he allowed a full contribution. These aspects are illustrated throughout, but especially in chapters 1 and 7. Campbell believed in universal education bestowing on it temporal and religious responsibilities. He allotted church and state complementary functions, requiring them to work harmoniously in institutionalizing national education. His early concept of denominationalism is explored in chapter 2. However, in the 1850s society proved incapable of deciding the respective roles for church and state in education. This and Campbell's efforts in seeking a national school system are explored in chapters 3 and 4. Secretaryship of the Denominational School Board provided Campbell with an opportunity of applying administrative solutions to denominational school problems. He always endeavoured to apply educational principles and obtain an adequate and fair distribution of funds. But events smothered him. Rather than become a political tool,he resigned the secretaryship in 1859. Chapters 5 and 6 treat these themes. From the perimeter Campbell tried to save national education from secularism prior to 1872. Applying the principle of freedom of conscience, he asked that the state remain neutral on religious instruction. But unable to meet all requirements of society concurrently, it chose to equate secularism with neutrality. Campbell advised Anglicans to seek a "common Scriptural basis" compromise with other Protestant churches from which they might stand firm against secular liberalism. However, as chapters 8 and 9 demonstrate, his advice went unheeded. Finally, Campbell was reluctant to concede secularism a victory and accept the consequences, still hoping to revive a defunct church-state partnership. Although historically ignored, it is argued throughout that he made a considerable and worthy contribution to 19th century education.
-
ItemThe transition from concrete to formal operational thinking : some aspects of Piaget's theory of cognitive development( 1974)The theoretical and research literature related to the transition from concrete operational to formal operational thinking was critically reviewed. The numerous unresolved issues were discussed. Within this contextual framework a study was proposed to investigate one of the issues needing clarification. A test of memory span for digits from the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (Wechsler 1949), a non-verbal test of general ability Raven s 1938 Progressive Matrices (A C E R 1958), and a test of formal operational thinking the test of the Oscillation of a Pendulum (Inhelder & Piaget 1958) were administered to 30 subjects from Grade 6 at a Melbourne suburban primary school. The sample contained equal numbers of boys and girls whose ages ranged from 10 10 to 12 3. The main aim of the study was to investigate the hypothesis proposed by McLaughlin (1963) that there is a significant relationship between short-term memory ability, as measured by a test of digit span and level of thinking as evidenced on a Piagetian test of formal reasoning ability. It was further hypothesised that this relationship is independent of general ability as measured by a conventional intelligence test. Both these hypotheses were supported by the results. Discussion centred on an attempted explanation of the findings in the light of otner evidence on their implications for further research and on a number of questions raised by aspects of this study.
-
ItemThe attainment of conservation of number : acceleration by training( 1974)The literature concerning the acceleration of conservation of number was surveyed and a theoretical construct underlying successful training studies was suggested. On this basis an experimental study was executed comparing the relative efficacy of two number conservation training procedures (a) empirical return and (b) sensory-motor analogue of reversibility. 16 non-conserving subjects were trained by each procedure and compared with 16 control group subjects on immediate and delayed post-tests for conservation of number, discontinuous quantity, and liquid. The empirical return procedure subjects performed significantly better than the control subjects on conservation of number at both the immediate and delayed post-tests. The sensory-motor reversibility procedure subjects performed significantly better than control group subjects on conservation of number at the immediate post-test only. No significant difference was observed between training procedures. Transfer to other areas of conservation was not observed. The means by which subjects appeared to make use of the training and the apparent absence of change in operational level is discussed.
-
ItemPost-world war II development of commercial courses for girls in Victorian technical schools, with special reference to the Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology, 1945-1970( 1974)In the inter-war years (1919- 1939), commercial courses, traditionally part of the technical system of education and fast becoming the province of girls, suffered from the effects of the economic depression, made some slight gains during the recovery years and achieved importance in the war years. In the post-World War II years growing community interest in education in general, and technical education in particular, reflected the social and economic climate of the rapidly changing 1950s and 1960s. High population growth and an affluent society created new educational needs, and industry required new technical college courses to meet technological developments and the continuing emergence of new knowledge. Occurring initially when Victorian resources were being channelled mainly into other priorities owing to post-war conditions, these demands caused a crisis in education in the late 1950s and in the 1960s, the Victorian Government being unable to support the expansion of tertiary education to its fullest extent. Therefore the Commonwealth Government granted, under certain conditions, financial aid to tertiary technical education and, in Victoria, the already existing Victoria Institute of Colleges became the guardian of the course standards of its affiliated C.A.E.s. Thus technical education at the tertiary level was eventually in a position to offer its own degrees and provide what promised to be a viable alternative to university education. The technical system of education appeared to represent a man's world and echoed the general education practice of the day as far as girls were concerned, thus reflecting the community's attitude to the place of women in Australian society. Tradition was the over-riding influence on what girls were taught and, as a necessary corollary, the kind of careers they followed. Hence it transpired that girls confined their abilities to a narrow range of female occupations, one of the chief of these being office work. The popularity of office work in the 1950s and 1960s was reflected in the growing number of students enrolling for commercial courses in the technical system. Technical commercial education responded increasingly to community and industrial demands, and endeavoured to maintain relevance to the changing times as it pursued higher standards and created a new concept of vocational training at both junior and senior levels. With the onset of the 1970s commercial education in the Victorian technical system provided all but one of the known commercial courses and, in keeping with the technical educational philosophy of the times, retained its established diploma. In the pursuit of professional status for the potential secretary, degree courses in secretarial work were foreshadowed in two Victorian C.A.E.s, while the Institute of Private Secretaries (Australia) sought professional status for the secretary already within the workforce.
-
ItemThe sixth-form college in England and Tasmania( 1974)The sixth-form college is an experiment in the organisation of education for the sixteen to nineteen year old student. An examination of the historical context of its evolution reveals its origins in the demands for expansion of upper secondary education and in the concern for a more equitable and broader-based provision for the expanded student body. Further examination exposes the social and political factors promoting and retarding its development. What began in most cases as a practical expedient became an institution providing a wide range of courses and study options to students, the academic or vocational emphasis depending on local conditions. The separate college idea attracted some idealists who saw an opportunity of establishing in the public sector of education an institution capable of rivalling the sixth-form of the better independent school. It had at the same time a strong appeal in its apparent economy and efficiency. It could offer a centralisation and concentration of specialist teachers and resources to provide for perhaps eight hundred students. Establishment of actual colleges has been cautious, few authorities being prepared, like the Tasmanian Education Department or the Teesside Education Committee to give the scheme unqualified approval. Earlier ideas of academic exclusiveness have been modified by the emergence of the "new sixth-former", the fifteen-plus student whose staying-on in full-time secondary education is as much a matter of law as of inclination. For the most part the purely academic college enjoyed a limited period of existence before the change in political or educational philosophy ordered its modification. The colleges of 1974 may differ rather significantly from those intended by their founders. However, what was enthusiastically regarded as a panacea for the problems of upper secondary organisation must now be soberly accepted as one of a number of possible ways of organising sixth-form education.
-
ItemA study of the use of computer managed instruction in the teaching of Fortran( 1974)Like many other studies of the effectiveness (in the cognitive domain) of innovatory teaching methods, this study revealed that for the sample of students involved, there were no statistically significant differences in the test scores obtained by the experimental group using a programmed text, when compared to the scores of those who learnt Fortran by the traditional lecture method. However, for the purposes of this study, such a finding is not of great importance per se; it was necessary as a first step to ensure that students using the individualised learning method were not academically disadvantaged. Certainly, the students who used the CMI exercises with traditional lectures (Group 2) performed better on the final examination than those who used the traditional exercises; the CMI exercises can therefore be claimed to be of positive benefit to the students. (From conclusions)
-
ItemSchools and teacher training in the Veneto (Italy) 1815-1870( 1974)Education in the Veneto (also known as Venezia Euganea) was given, in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, mainly by religious Orders of both sexes. Little was done for the mass of the people. The most famous order was the Society of Jesus (Jesuits), principally concerned with secondary and university education. The teachers in this Order had to complete the rigorous course of the inferior colleges (corresponding to the later gymnasiums and lyceums) and the superior course (corresponding to university level). Those permanent teachers whose task it was to train other teachers had to complete even further university level studies. Uniformity of teaching techniques and methods was part of the Jesuit system. Under the guidance of experienced teachers the student received a thorough training in these techniques and methods. When the Jesuits were expelled in 1773 Gasparo Gozzi was given the task of planning reforms, but little change occurred. From 1805 to 1814 the Veneto became part of the Italic Kingdom set up by Napoleon. Various decrees sought to improve the quality of education and teaching but as these were mainly communal responsibilities they remained mainly in the hands of private institutions and religious orders. However, all teachers were required to make an oath of loyalty to the King (Napoleon) and provisions were made for the training of teachers for State Schools. The training took place either in selected major elementary schools (a three month course) or in normal schools (a six month course). When Austria returned to the Veneto it set up a state school system modelled on that of Austria itself. The teacher was confined to a rigidly prescribed curriculum and his work was closely supervised by an inspectorial system. Major difficulties arose in providing sufficient schools, trained teachers and enforcing the compulsory education provisions. Austria continued and extended the provisions for elementary teacher training made during the Italic Kingdom. Detailed instructions were set out regarding syllabii and teacher duties and responsibilities. The teaching method favoured in the elementary schools was the "normal" method which was composed of four parts - the use of initial letters, the use of tables, the use of reading in unison and the use of interrogations. The Austrian model also served for secondary education. After elementary school the students proceeded onto either a gymnasium or a technical school. These technical schools provided more practical courses and taught modern languages in contrast to the gymnasium where purely classical (Latin and Greek) were offered. The government prescribed the subjects to be taught and the texts to be used in all government, communal and episcopal schools, at least until the Concordat, signed between the Church and Austria in 1855, when the Church was given a freer hand in this area. The Austrian government also restricted the independence of private institutions which had a long tradition in the Veneto. When the Veneto became part of the new Kingdom of Italy in 1866, the numbers of schools were increased in all areas and a re-organized system of teacher training was introduced.
-
ItemProfessional registration and advice in state education: a comparative study of the origins and roles of statutory bodies connected with registration and advice in the administration of education in New South Wales and Victoria( 1974)The provision of educational services is a major task of Australian state political systems. At various times, in efforts to moderate the bureaucratic tendencies of centralised administrations by bringing a wider range of opinion to bear on the administration of public education, bodies to advise the responsible minister, and Parliament in some cases, have been established. An examination of the work of the Council of Public Education in Victoria, established ostensibly for this purpose, reveals that there is a confusion over the role and influence of advise within a state political administrative structure. This inquiry postulates that there are two basic, but disparate, functions of advice: a political function where representatives of interest groups can put their views to the Minister, and an evaluative function where the policies and practices of the public sector are evaluated. The formation of the Council of Public Education was justified to the public in terms of the latter function, but other features of the Council, such as its representative membership, are more like those of a body with political functions. This disjunction between structure and function, together with a confusion over the extent and use of its powers, have rendered the Council ant: ineffectual evaluative advisory body. The attitudes of administrators and other interested parties towards. educational advisory bodies are illuminated' by an investigation of the origins of these bodies in Victoria and New South Wales. The comparison of developments in the two states indicates that the concept of an evaluative advisory body, operating free of administrative and political interference, is incompatible with the present system of centralised control of public education in these states.
-
ItemSources of maladjustment in male sixth form students( 1974)Following Hohne (1951) and a pilot study by Conway (1960) an in-depth investigation was made of 96 sixth form boys from two large metropolitan private secondary schools - one a Catholic college, the other a grammar school. It was planned to test hypotheses that there would be significant differences in personal adjustment between both schools and curricular groupings (Maths-Science versus Humanities- Commercial). It was further planned to investigate the sources of various kinds of maladjustment by qualitative analysis, using individually administered projective tests and interviews. Apart from an appreciable difference in I.Q. between the two curricular groups, no really significant difference was found between schools and groups. There were, however, some differences in the kind of values espoused by contrasted schools and contrasted groups. Furthermore, qualitative analysis established, with a large measure of confidence, that the chief sources of stress experienced by students in their terminal secondary year were not curricular or scholastic. Maladjustments from domestic and extracurricular sources were found to decisively outrank those deriving (or believed to have derived) from the requirements imposed by the syllabus and school milieu. This finding was considered to have some value as a basis for criteria for further enquiry into the relationship between intrapsychic stresses and educational performance.