The role of the chaplaincy in the Bermudian convict establishment is best delineated by a case study of one of the longest serving chaplains, Rev. Robert Mantach (1795 - 1853). In the face a monumental adversity, Mantach established and superintended schools on board each hulk at Ireland Island. He helped both educated and Irish Roman Catholic prisoners obtain mitigation of sentences. His experiences as chaplain will help demonstrate how the British Government perceived the role of chaplain and how chaplains were instruments of Government policy and the extent to which this was consistent with their sacred function.