Melbourne Law School - Theses

Permanent URI for this collection

Now showing 1 - 1 of 1

The concept of dishonesty in the law of theft in Victoria and England

Kornblum, Abraham Zali ( 1983)

This paper is en empirical examination of the concept of dishonesty in England and Victoria from its inception as a result of the recommendations of the Criminal Law Revision Committee in England to the present state of the authorities in England and Victoria. The paper follows the authorities in chronological order first in England and then in Victoria. Each authority is examined and analysed in order to see how the Courts have come to terms with the new concept in defining it, how the concept has developed and changed and the connection of the new concept with the old concepts of larceny and related offences. General criticisms are offered where it is believed that the Courts have strayed from the concept or where the Courts appear confused about defining the concept or where the reasoning appears erroneous. The adequacy or otherwise of the concept as it presently stands is assessed and what advantages and disadvantages exist in the two jurisdictions. Finally, a proposal for reform is suggested having regard to the present state of the authorities.