Melbourne Law School - Theses

Permanent URI for this collection

Search Results

Now showing 1 - 10 of 13
  • Item
    Thumbnail Image
    ‘Industrial disputes’ and the jurisdiction of the federal industrial tribunal
    Stern, Esther ( 1993)
    What constitutes an 'industrial dispute' for the purposes of s. 51 (xxxv) of the Commonwealth Constitution and s. 4 of the Australian Industrial Relations Act 1988 (Cth) is crucial for the determination of union-employer relations. Ultimately the ambit of the phrase 'industrial dispute' determines those matters that may legitimately be raised by a federally registered union with an employer before the Australian Industrial Relations Commission (hereafter the federal tribunal). The central thesis advanced here is that since 1904 the High Court has employed alternating approaches to identifying an 'industrial dispute'. One approach is that an 'industrial dispute' means no more than the traditionally perceived notion of an individual employer-employee dispute. The other approach is a much broader view, in that such a dispute relates to collective employment relations. Put at its most basic level, I submit in this thesis that the jurisdiction of the federal tribunal has been shaped less by the particular words 'industrial dispute' than by the perception of the kind of employment relationship with which these words are concerned. (From introduction)
  • Item
    Thumbnail Image
    From committee to commission?: the evolution of the Mekong River Agreements with reference to the Murray-Darling Basin Agreements
    Chi, Bui Kim ( 1997)
    The Murray-Darling Basin Agreements had their genesis in disputes between upstream States (Victoria and New South Wales) and a downstream State (South Australia) over the use of basin waters. While originally the disputes concerned navigation, for most of the twentieth century, the rivers' use for irrigation has been of more importance. The 1914 Murray Waters Agreement, between the Commonwealth government and those of the three basin States, was essentially a compact defining allocation of water to the parties concerned. Agreements on the Murray-Darling basin have evolved from this narrowly-based concept to one in which the natural resources of the basin are to be managed as a whole. At the same time, an institutional structure for the operation of water control works has developed which is able to make policy for resource management in the basin. The present Agreement covers water, land and environmental resources, and contains provisions for strategies intended to enable the integrated and sustainable development of the basin in the future. The Mekong Agreements, rather than representing a consistent evolution towards a legal framework for comprehensive basin management, have instead reflected the political evolution of the region. The 1957 Statute was a limited compact establishing the Mekong Committee for the Co-ordination of Investigation. It made no provision for basin management, nor for the equitable use or sharing of basin water. It was established to a large extent as an expression of the influence of the United States in the region. Its successor, the Joint Declaration of 1975, was a more comprehensive document, and used the Helsinki Rules of 1966 as a model. While it included principles of cooperation between riparian States, which could be used to ensure equitable use of water, it did not provide an adequate institutional structure for the management of basin resources. The 1975 Declaration was drafted during a hiatus in the conflict in South East Asia; and because one of the signatory States - the Republic of Vietnam (South Vietnam) - ceased to exist with the fall of Saigon, it was never applied. Interim arrangements were in place until 1995 during the absence of Cambodia from the international body politic. The drafting of new arrangements was then precipitated by Thailand's expulsion of the head of the Mekong Secretariat, effectively bringing the status quo to an end. The Mekong Agreement of 1995 establishes a new Commission, and states its purpose to be the sustainable development of basin resources. It relies on a co-operative approach, rather than establishing comprehensive criteria for water use, with the exception of the Mekong mainstream in the dry season. In addition, there is no provision for projects on tributaries to be submitted to the Commission for an evaluation of their effect downstream. In contrast to the arrangement under the Murray-Darling Basin Agreement, it confers no powers on the Commission to control basin waters, or to manage the regime in an effective manner, and to ensure equity between basin States. If development in a rational and equitable manner is assured, legal and institutional arrangements should be able to endure the ebb and flow of international relations. The need for an appropriate instrument to accommodate changing circumstances in the Mekong basin is made the more important by the prospect of the two upper basin States (China and Myanmar) joining the Agreement in the future. The Murray-Darling Basin Agreement, while it is a less than ideal model for legislation in this field, nevertheless offers guidance on how the new Mekong Agreement may be developed. This applies both to the management of basin resources, and to the preparation of strategies directed towards the objectives of the Agreement. The 1995 Mekong Agreement will be examined in the perspective that legislation should be stable and not static. While the Agreement has been duly praised for its intention of developing the basin through co-operation between States, this thesis looks at ways in which it may be improved. Significant issues effecting the choice of institutional and legal arrangements in both basins are identified and discussed. Findings from this comparison suggest a context for the further evolution of the institutional and legal framework to support the rational management and sustainable development of the Mekong basin.
  • Item
    Thumbnail Image
    The law relating to the protection and treatment of animals in Victoria
    McInnes, Susan Elizabeth ( 1984)
    The subject matter of this thesis is the Victorian law relating to the protection and treatment of animals. Brief reference is made by way of comparison with the laws of other jurisdictions. This thesis attempts to survey the law and examine the way the law provides some protection for animals even though animals are not capable of holding or enforcing legal rights in our system of law. This is generally by way of protecting property rights of owners, the public morality or the public interest in the natural resource of animals. As traditional western attitudes have generally accepted man's dominant status over animals, the law reflects the greater weight to be given to human needs or benefits in balancing any conflicting interests of animals with human interests. Therefore, against the historical background of Chapter 1, the remaining chapters set out the law protecting animals attempting to show how the law has balanced the various competing interests involved. In Chapter 2 the Victorian statutory provisions relating to cruelty to animals are surveyed. They reflect that cruelty to animals is generally prohibited under the Protection of Animals Act 1966. However the concept of cruelty applied to animals requires that there be a balancing between the pain inflicted on the animal and the circumstances surrounding the infliction of pain. The statutory provisions reflect the concept. Cruelty is generally not prohibited under the Act if it can be justified as being reasonable in the circumstances, often on the, grounds that it can be justified in terms of serving a human need. The Act goes on to provide specific exemptions from the cruelty provisions for activities which are generally accepted in Western Society as essential or convenient for human activities or needs and these are not prohibited. The major exemptions relate to using animals for farming purposes, hunting purposes, experimental purposes and exterminating vermin. These are discussed in Chapters 3, 4 and 5. Chapter 6 surveys the law relating to animals used for entertainment purposes. The present law reflects a desire to balance the need to prohibit those sports and entertainments which offend against the moral standards of the community such as blood sports and the need to retain those activities where ill-treatment of animals can be justified in terms of a legitimate object such as an educational interest, in the case of wildlife parks and zoos or a sporting or commercial interest in the case of horse racing. Chapter 7 looks briefly at the Victorian law relating to the conservation of wildlife. The law on this subject reflects the Christian philosophy of preserving all animal species for God's kingdom to come. This basis for the law is strengthened by an increasing awareness of the need to preserve all the animal species as a requirement for preserving the natural balance of animal species necessary for the survival of all plant and animal life. However the law provides varying degrees of protection depending on the animal concerned. Animals which are not native to Australia and animals regarded as vermin do not receive this special protection, because their survival is not essential to the natural balance to be preserved. The law also makes exemptions to allow wildlife to be used for educational purposes such as in wildlife parks and for restricted commercial purposes, such as for sale and for breeding. Thus the law on this subject also reflects the balancing processes involved in preserving wildlife but allowing for some human activities which are recognised or established as sufficiently important to be exceptions to the rule of preserving wildlife. The law is, unless otherwise stated, as at February 1983.
  • Item
    Thumbnail Image
    The law and transsexuals
    Baczynski, Mary ( 1982)
    The development of our Common Law as well as the law of most other societies has been based on certain fundamental assumptions about sex. Only two sexes exist, male and female. Everyone is classified as belonging to one or the other by anatomical sex at birth. A person's social and legal status may depend on his or her sex, which until recently was regarded as immutable. Transsexual surgery became a modern reality in 1952 when the much publicized case of Christine Jorgensen was brought to world attention. Since that time transsexuality has become both a dilemma and controversy in medicine, psychiatry and the law. There is no clear legal theory for determining how to accommodate the transsexual into our legal system. with the development in modern surgery the essential criteria for determining sex are being re examined. Although the dilemma of sex determination may initially seem far removed from the real concerns of lawyers, recent cases such as Corbett v Corbett , M.T. v J.T. and C and D3 make clear the need to re-evaluate accepted legal classification. (From Introduction)
  • Item
    Thumbnail Image
    Capital gains tax and the resources industry
    Wade, Timothy Cardwell ( 1988)
    In one of the most significant events in the history of government funding since the introduction of uniform taxation, the Federal Labor Treasurer, Paul Keating, announced the introduction of a Capital Gains Tax for Australia on 19 September 1985. This paper assesses the application of this new form of impost to one of the largest and most capital intensive industry sectors in Australia, the resources industry. Such an analysis must necessarily be considered in the context of the peculiar Federal and State regulatory frameworks governing the exploration and exploitation of minerals and petroleum. In particular, the following discussion will focus on the precise scope and operation of the terms 'asset' and 'property' - which together operate as the fulcrum of the capital gains tax provisions. It is the object of this paper to show that non-proprietary 'assets' are not adequately included within the ambit of the capital gains tax provisions. On the premise that property law concepts necessarily underpin the capital gains tax provisions, an examination will be conducted of the 'proprietary' nature of various mining rights, including permits, leases, licences, royalty interests and information. The potential application of capital gains tax in the resources industry turns heavily on the resolution of this 'threshold' issue. It will be seen that the capital gains tax provisions incorporated into the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) (the Assessment Act) do not, apart from three separate sections, address themselves specifically to the resources industry. It is this decision to deny the resources industry special consideration that has created the most widespread uncertainty and enduring resentment, particularly in view of the industry's historically preferred tax treatment. It will be submitted that specific attention must be given in the capital gains tax provisions to the wide variety of traditional mining and petroleum 'interests', rather than attempting to mould them into a definitional context with a clear cornmon law proprietary bias.
  • Item
    Thumbnail Image
    Taxation of superannuation and other termination payments
    Adsett, Ashley B. ( 1992)
    Thesis Plan: This thesis provides an overview of the law and relevant procedures of the taxation of superannuation and other termination payments. Specifically the thesis details the various changes to the concessional taxation treatment afforded such payments from 1/7/1983 to the present. In addition various policy issues are examined in light of the recent release of the Federal Government Statement on the topic re “Security In Retirement: Planning For Tomorrow Today”.
  • Item
    Thumbnail Image
    Electronic commerce on the Internet: legal issues of contracts on the World Wide Web
    Tan, Harry S. K. ( 1996)
    In the early nineties, despite the widespread knowledge of the potential uses of the Internet, many businesses and information technologists scoffed at using it as a medium for business. It was thought that the technology, capacity and critical mass would not make the Internet a suitable medium for electronic commerce. However, by the last quarter of 1994 there were over 10,000 companies offering information and services for sale over the Internet. This figure is now expected to grow to over one million businesses by the year 2000 despite the lack of clear laws governing commercial activity on the Internet. This paper is intended to investigate the issues of electronic commerce and the difficulties contracting parties face on the Internet which would not normally arise in conventional transactions. In addition, as one of the primary interest in the Internet comes from the easy and quick access to overseas markets, the paper will also consider the international aspects of Internet transactions. It is not the intention for the paper to be a comprehensive or definitive treatise on contract or international law, but rather consider the intriguing issues raised by electronic contracting in the domestic and international context. Chapter 1 is a concise introduction to the technology of the Internet and its workings to provide a background for the discussion that follows. Chapter 2 looks at the unresolved international issues that will arise out of trans-border Internet trade. Chapters 3 and 4 will then review the impact of Internet technology and how it challenged the current practices of proving the existence of contracts and the formation of contract. In chapter 5 we look at how the law deals with the specific issues of software being sold on-line and the attempts by Internet-stores to avoid statutory conditions designed to protect the consumer.
  • Item
    Thumbnail Image
    Legislating our right to die
    Hum, Fiona Catherine ( 1997)
    This thesis argues that the enactment by the Northern Territory Legislative Assembly in 1995 of the Rights of the Terminally Ill Act 1995 (NT), (‘the Act’) did not advance, but rather diminished, a patient’s right to request and receive assistance to die at the time it was in operation. The author suggests the Act failed to achieve the goal of balancing competing interests (patient autonomy versus procedural safeguards) and instead created unnecessarily complex legal and institutional obstacles for terminally ill patients. Despite the positively stated intentions of the main proponent of the legislation, Mr Perron, the parliamentary drafters of the Act erred on the side of caution. Consequently, it was difficult, if not at times impossible, for persons to use the Act in a way which led to results consistent with the Act’s intended purpose. The complex procedural regime set up by the Act, indicates a regressive shift from a patient’s right to undertake an autonomous decision-making process towards a decision process governed by medical paternalism and State intervention. The central argument presented in this thesis is that the rights of patients to take control of their own body and the manner of their own death, will be eroded rather than enhanced if the legislation in the form discussed becomes enacted. Possible alternatives to legislating on euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide are suggested by the author.
  • Item
    Thumbnail Image
    The new Philippine mineral regime: an opportunity for investment?
    Mander, Kirsten G. ( 1994)
    A ring of fire encircles the Pacific Basin, an unstable region of earthquakes, faulting and intense volcanic activity. It stretches from the tip of South America, up through the Andes, across the Aleutians, down through Japan and the Philippines to the tip of New Zealand. To the countries in the region, this geological volatility is both a misfortune and a blessing. It was a misfortune, indeed, to the local people who lived around the slopes of the Mt. Pinatubo volcano in the Philippines when it erupted in 1991. Their homes and farms were buried under metres of volcanic ash and it will be many years before they can return to the area to live. Yet when viewed from a broader perspective this geological instability has been a real boon to the Philippines, not merely because of the substantial export industry it has generated in souvenirs made out of volcanic ash, but because it is this same instability which has made the region fertile and resource rich. Over millions of years the tremendous pressures from within the earth have forced hot, mineral rich fluids up through faults created by earthquakes and faulting in the sub-surface rock. In that rock the minerals have cooled and concentrated to become mineral deposits, lying hidden underground until erosion reveals their presence to the human eye. Many of the world's major mineral deposits have been discovered in this region, such as the spectacular Hishikari deposit in Southern Japan, Erstberg in Indonesia and Bougainville in Papua New Guinea. The impact that this mineral endowment has had on the economic development of some of the countries in the region has been enormous. In PNG, for example, minerals make up more than 80% of the country's export income and generate revenue of over Aus$350 Million per annum. In Australia, they make up around 40% of export income, generating revenue of around Aus$30 Billion per annum. The significance of such revenue flows, particularly to developing countries, can not be underestimated. However a country's high geological potential will remain just that, unrealised potential, unless the country has access to sufficient funds to explore for new mineral deposits and to develop them when they are found. Few developing countries have sufficient domestic capital available to fund mineral development and for this reason many countries have in recent years been competing to attract foreign investment to assist in the development of their mineral industries. Vietnam, Laos, India, Peru, Argentina, Chile and others have all been taking steps to promote foreign investment by removing impediments to foreign investment, reducing government take and offering investment incentives. At the same time, Australian mining companies have been increasingly looking overseas for investment opportunities. Australian mining companies, in particular, have been seeking to place a greater percentage of their exploration/development budgets offshore in order to minimise their exposure to Australian sovereign risk, engendered by Australian Government decisions such as Coronation Hill, world heritage listings and more recently the Mabo legislation.
  • Item
    Thumbnail Image
    The court and the factory the legal construction of occupational health and safety offences in Victoria
    Johnstone, Richard Stephen ( 1994)
    This thesis reports on an empirically based study of the manner in which Victorian Magistrates Courts constructed occupational health and safety (OHS) issues when hearing prosecutions for offences under the Industrial Safety, Health and Welfare Act 1981 (the ISHWA) and the Occupational Health and Safety Act 1985 (OHSA) from 1983 to 1991. These statutes established OHS standards for employers and other relevant parties. The State government enforced these standards through an OHS inspectorate which had a range of enforcement powers, including prosecution. After outlining the historical development of Victoria’s OHS legislation, the magistracy’s historical role in its enforcement, and the development of an enforcement culture in which inspectors viewed prosecution as a last resort, the study shows how the key provisions of the ISHWA and OHSA required occupiers of workplaces and employers to provide and maintain safe systems of work, including the guarding of dangerous machinery. Using a wide range of empirical research methods and legal materials, it shows how the enforcement policies, procedures and practices of the inspectorate heavily slanted inspectors workplace investigations and hence prosecutions towards a restricted and often superficial, analysis of incidents (or “events”) most of which involved injuries on machinery. There was evidence, however, that after the establishment of the Central Investigation Unit in 1989 cases were more thoroughly investigated and prosecuted. From 1990 the majority of prosecutions were taken under the employer’s general duty provisions, and by 1991 there was evidence that prosecutions were focusing on matters other than machinery guarding.