Melbourne Law School - Theses
Permanent URI for this collection
Search Results
1 - 6 of 6
-
Item
-
ItemThe development of Australian law to protect undisclosed business information( 1998)Traditionally, information has not generally been regarded by the common law as being property and able to be legally protected in the same way as land, money or goods. Australian courts have demonstrated great reluctance to change this approach, even though information is increasingly considered to be a valuable asset, particularly by the business community. However, a change in the way information is regarded has taken place over the last four to five decades, resulting primarily from the increased use of computer technology. In Australian law, organisations or individuals who wish to restrict access to their business information and keep it confidential currently have limited legal means to achieve their aim. The breach of confidence action, contract law, copyright law and criminal law may all be used to protect information from unauthorised access or use but only to a certain extent. In most instances these traditional legal approaches require that there is a confidential or contractual relationship between the parties, that the information be in an original form, or that the unauthorised access be made using computer technology. There are particular deficiencies in the legal protection available when undisclosed business information is accessed by a party outside a contractual or confidential relationship, often through improper means. Ways in which these deficiencies, particularly in respect to the breach of confidence action, could be overcome have been proposed by a number of law reform bodies, in Australia and overseas. However, no legislative amendments adopting these proposals have been introduced in Australia and judicial decisions indicate that the courts are likely to continue a conservative approach to the protection of information to avoid creation of barriers to the free flow of information. Different legal approaches to the protection of business information have developed in continental Europe and America. However a review shows that deficiencies in the protection offered have not been fully overcome in these jurisdictions. More recently, a number of international developments have taken place which are of significance to the protection of business information. The developments take different forms, either as binding international agreements, or non-binding agreements. Examples are the Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Agreement (TRIPS); the OECD Guidelines of Security for Information Systems and for Cryptography Policy; and the WIPO Model Provisions for Unfair Competition. These agreements establish new international standards relating to the protection of business information. The way in which these international agreements may become part of Australian domestic law and policy can be predicted and explained by analysing the nature and form of the relevant international agreements and the process by which they may become part of domestic law; by having regard to recent developments in this field in other countries; by analysing Australia's response to similar developments in the past, for example, the OECD Guidelines on the Protection of Privacy and Transborder flows of Personal Data; and by reviewing Australia's response so far to the latest developments relating to the protection of confidential business information.
-
ItemInteraction between commercial & legal aspects of project finance in Australasia( 1997)The project finance technique emerged as a result of legal principles evolving to meet commercial needs. Its value - enabling companies to fund projects on other than their own credit standing and to diversify risks associated with projects - has been proved by a remarkable string of major developments which were unlikely to have been undertaken without such a financing method. Over the years, the technique has been adapted to a range of applications and industries. One of its most recent uses has been in private sector development of public infrastructure projects. It is in this climate of continued need for project financing that this thesis seeks to examine its development to date, its strengths and its weaknesses, and to consider what changes, if any, are needed to ensure its continued usefulness in the future. The growing body of work known as 'economic analysis of law' is used as a key to understanding these issues and to suggest possible ways forward. Risk is identified as being central to the project financing process. Its identification, allocation and mitigation are the building blocks of the technique. Parties trade risks and contractual arrangements are put in place to give effect to these compacts. These contracts have often been creative, responding to the commercial requirements of the particular development and the parties involved. Novel processes have been devised to deal with cases of project or operator failure, providing self governing and self executing regimes for the developments. These self contained mechanisms are a response to the fact that court adjudication of disputes in these transactions is often inappropriate. The sophistication of these arrangements, however, has also resulted in significant transaction costs. Lengthy and complex documentation is characteristic in these financings. The costs begin at the outset of the transaction in the time and money involved in negotiating documentation and, on an on-going basis, arise through the significant reporting burden usually imposed on borrowers and the restrictive provisions which require continual lender involvement in project decision making. The lengthy, detailed documentation provides the project management regime as it usually stipulates in great detail how the project is to be operated and what the borrower can and cannot do. However, the very long terms of these financings (at times 17 or 18 years), mean that parties are unlikely to succeed in anticipating and dealing comprehensively with every imaginable contingency. The use of such lengthy, detailed documentation will, therefore, be reviewed and a theoretical analysis presented of why project participants have adopted this strategy. This thesis also recommends alternative strategies for structuring the project finance relationship. The optimal solution for any project should still be determined on the specific circumstances on the case and is likely to combine elements of the current approach with some of the proposals suggested.
-
Item
-
ItemThe suitability rule : a critical analysis of section 851 of the Corporations Law( 1991)A securities adviser must tailor his investment recommendations to the investment objectives, financial situation and particular needs of his client. In the United States, this has become known as the 'Suitability Rule', imposed by the National Association of Securities Dealers (NASD), the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) and, until recently, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). In Australia, we have gone further than , developing mere suitability rules. We have developed a statutory obligation under the guise of section 851 of the Corporations Law (CL), which imposes a suitability obligation on securities advisers who make recommendations to investors. However, the 'Suitability Rule' remains, in Australia at least, an amorphous concept. There have been no recorded cases to determine what are the securities adviser's duties under our suitability provision. The Suitability Sules adopted by the NASD, the SEC and the NYSE themselves differ significantly. Can the Australian Courts draw on the American experience as a guide in Australia's embryonic development of a securities advisers independent duty under our legislation? Chapter 1 of this paper will consider the relationship between the securities adviser and the investor. Chapter 2 will trace the development of the Suitability Rule in Australia and the United States. Chapter 3 will examine the rationale behind the Suitability Rule. Chapter 4 will discuss the application of the Suitability Rule and what control it has over securities advisers who make recommendations. Finally, this paper will consider whether the Suitability Rule should be redefined to further enhance investor protection.
-
ItemThe rights of members of superannuation funds( 1991)In this thesis, the current law in respect of the rights of members of superannuation funds is examined. Trust law as well as a number of statutes including the trustee legislation of the various states and territories, the Occupational Superannuation Standards Act and Regulations, the Income Tax Assessment Act, the Life Insurance Act, the Corporations Act and certain pieces of industrial legislation are relevant to this inquiry. The actual provisions contained in the trust deed which governs the superannuation fund will also be crucial and the effect of usual superannuation trust deed provisions which are likely to be of most concern to fund members are considered. A case is then put that there is a need for reform and some proposals for suitable changes to the present law are suggested. Finally, the changes in respect of superannuation announced in the 1991 Federal budget are considered and the conclusion is reached that while the changes proposed there seem to be worthwhile, many areas remain which require reform.